Calycanthus floridus, a.k.a. Sweetshrub, gets it's name for the fruity scent of it's fair sized flowers. Google the thing and you'll find loads of people praising the scent and encouraging it's placement by the patio. I wonder if everyone's nose is working though because the one I apparently planted 3 years ago smells like rotting crab apples. It's very repelling, especially when the bloom first opens. It's pollinated specifically by tiny and fairly bland looking beetles. No Bees, and No Butterflies. It isn't even the host plant to any sort of Lepidoptera. It really has no place in my garden but I planted one anyway out of confusion years ago.
Native Plants of the Northeast: A Guide for Gardening and Conservation is a book I got about 3 years before. In it I first learned of the Buttonbush that I was later encouraged to buy from the book "Bringing Nature Home." Since then "Native Plants of the Northeast" has gotten a new front cover and perhaps been expanded upon, so I don't know if this still applies. Basically the species name for a Sweetshrub and that of a Buttonbush were printed right next to one another. While making a plant wish list I must have written down the wrong one and ordered a Sweetshrub instead.
Having never seen either plant in person it was quite the mistake to make. Both have leaves forming in pairs, both get to be about the same size, and the only thing to really alert me I'd planted the wrong thing was the stem color. Buttonbush has a red stem while Sweetshrub is quite green.
The Sweetshrub went into shock the first year and only produced new growth instead of growing on existing wood. Sweetshrubs don't like it to wet while Buttonbushes can tolerate being 4 feet of water. Sweetshrubs burn up a bit in full sun so I'd say they benefit from some partial shade. (Perhaps afternoon shade)? So I'd planted it in the full sun spot with almost no drainage in the yard, and no wonder the poor thing went into shock. The second year it reclaimed the wood thankfully. Finally we're on the third year and it's started flowering. From what I've seen on the internet they're nice looking shrubs at least.
It's not on my favorite list at all and I've since transplanted it. Besides some wilting on the first day it's taking the whole move really well. I expected some loss of flowers or leaves or for it to die all together. But really it's just doing great. It's still flowering even.
So that brings us to the second part of my story.
How I bought a Buttonbush.
So that was my feel good moment of the day. I recommended she treat it as though it were a native Butterfly Bush because it really is in many ways. The flowers occur in clumps, or in this case balls, they're tube shaped, and even lightly scented but not as pungent as a Butterfly Bush. They're more sweet smelling but not as strong, unfortunately. It's even the host plant to at least one Giant Silk Moth. I hope to prove how great of a plant this is when mine starts blooming real good.